I take pride in having authored a book where every word is mine. So what if I did the opposite? 

To understand the state of AI slop and how pervasive it can be, I used AI to “author” a new book. You can read The Barking Ceases yourself at https://aiwrotethisbook.com/. You'll find the book, the process, reviews from LLMs posing as book reviewers, and more. Here, you get the story behind the story.

It begins with a note I received a few weeks ago from avid reader Noel Guinane of Blood & Treasure, informing me about Type.ai, an AI book writer and editor. I had to try it.

It wasn't my first time writing a book with AI. In 2023, I used a tool called Omniscience to write a couple of books based on a single prompt, adding in a few files of mine for added color. I was able to go from a prompt to a book live on Amazon within an hour, though I removed the Amazon listings before my actual human-written book was published. I still have printed copies. They're not very good, but they're not as awful as one might expect. Granted, I only skimmed a few pages.

Type.ai is different. It says it's an editor and creative partner rather than an author. It's designed to help you bring ideas to life. Yes, you can do this with Claude, Gemini, and others, but I think there is a place for specialized tools, especially when there's a high payoff. 

If you're trying to sell books or use them for lead generation, you'll find that services to help launch a book can cost thousands to tens of thousands of dollars. Publishing suite Spines.com raised $64 million this month, and while it doesn’t disclose prices on its site, various online reviews cite prices ranging from $3,000 to more than $20,000 for its various packages. The pricier plans include more promotional assets, language translation, editorial and marketing support, and other extras. 

Type.ai cost me $48 (the monthly plan plus extra credits) to publish a 230-page book with about 80,000 words. My initial step was taking a document of dozens of pages of notes I amassed over years about ideas for stories based on the confusion around my infamous name. (Google it, or ChatGPT it, if you're confused.)

The plot of the book started to take shape. I don't know what the plot is, as I haven’t read The Barking Ceases. I didn't want human input affecting the book, but I did give it some ideas for tropes to consider. As I made progress with the work sporadically over a couple of weeks, I opened Gemini in the browser to give a slew of feedback about how to make this book better; I told Gemini it should be the next great American novel. I also tried to get Gemini to remove all the classic AI tells.

Trying to remove the AI from an AI-written book didn't help. Or, it didn't fool AI detector Pangram, which determined that 99% of the book was AI-written.

I haven't read the book yet, and I sure wasn't asking humans to review it, but I did ask some LLMs to pose as New York Times book critics to write reviews of it; the full reviews are on my site, and excerpts are below.

Gemini's "critic" called it "a wry, unexpectedly conscience-stricken debut — a cautionary tale for an era in which everyone is a brand, everything is content, and nobody checks the metadata until the bill comes due.”

ChatGPT was also kind but had its pointed critcisim: "Berkowitz is a talented descriptive writer, particularly when working with physical objects and urban environments… But he has a tendency to overdescribe."

Claude was harsh, but it still seemed to think there was something to salvage. It concluded, "My verdict: a very good premise and a handful of excellent scenes inside a book that doesn’t trust them. Cut a third, choose a genre, and let Maya, Lane, and Aly carry the weight, and this could be a sharp short novel."

None of this matters. The book doesn't have a soul to it. There's no point of view or perspective. It was “written” by algorithms. I'd hope it's not something anyone would want to read.

Type.ai isn't part of the problem. I'm using it in a way that it's not supposed to be used. There are so many points where it pauses and seems to demand human intervention, and I opted to give it the Gemini feedback instead. 

My experience creating this book underscores the need for third parties that vouch for a work's human provenance. I trust The New York Times reviewers and the Los Angeles County Museum of Art's curators to feature human-generated works. Yet I'd assume that some creators of AI-generated works would find ways to game Goodreads, Spotify, and other marketplaces unless such marketplace owners find more rigorous, authoritative ways to remove or set aside AI-generated content. The worst part of all this is that new, unknown artists may be deemed guilty of AI usage until proven innocent, and this could make it harder for them to find an audience.

One of the recurring lessons that AI teaches us is that we shouldn't do many or most of the things we can now do thanks to the latest technological advancements. 

Then again, thanks to AI, we get gems like this from The Barking Ceases: “My apartment smelled of radiator iron and the cinnamon oatmeal my eight-year-old daughter, Maya, had left in a plastic bowl on the counter. I tiptoed past her bedroom door. The nightlight—a soft silicone dinosaur cycling through pale green and indigo—cast a warm smudge across the hardwood. Maya was asleep on her stomach, one foot tangled in her duvet, her breathing untroubled by probate registries or the summer of 1977.”

Who needs Toni Morrison when AI gives you writing like that?

— David Berkowitz, Chief Community Officer, Marketecture Media

1

United Tells the Agents: No Ticket for You

Who: Travel Marketers, E-commerce Leads, Brand Marketers, Agency Strategists

What: United Airlines is restricting AI bots' access to its digital platforms, citing data security — the latest and loudest brand pushback against agents that plan and book trips, CNBC reports. United warned that sharing account credentials with third-party assistants risks unintended purchases, account changes, and unauthorized use of frequent-flyer miles, and that automated check-in creates regulatory exposure. The carrier will restrict access both directly and through travel agencies and aggregators, updating its booking, ticketing, and distribution policies. The industry's split is widening: Amazon blocks Meta's Muse, Walmart partners with it, and Expedia and Booking are working with OpenAI.

Why it matters: The agentic-commerce story just got its other shoe: brands that decide agents are a liability, not a channel. United's argument isn't Luddite — check-in carries legal attestations a bot can't make — and it gives every CMO the vocabulary for the "no" case. Marketers planning agent strategies now need two playbooks: one for being found by agents, one for controlling what they can touch.

2

IAB Draws the Map for AI Attribution

Who: Measurement Teams, Media Buyers, CMOs, Ad Tech Executives

What: IAB has released an "AI-Era Attribution Blueprint," a framework for deciding who gets credit when AI influences or completes a purchase, MarTech reports. It classifies conversions as human-owned, AI-assisted, or AI-executed, then asks who created the intent, who made the decision, and who completed the purchase — distinguishing between parties eligible to claim influence and those that actually get credit, with evidence requirements for each. The need is acute: 45% of ad buyers call comparing AI-driven and traditional journeys their top measurement challenge, and 44% admit using branded search and direct traffic as proxies for AI influence they can't track. The blueprint assigns homework across the chain: AI platforms must label AI-originated traffic and disclose paid versus organic recommendations, while agencies must separate platform-reported claims from independently verified ones.

Why it matters: Attribution is where AI hype goes to die, and IAB just put the problem on paper with a shared vocabulary. The 44% proxy stat is the confession that matters: Nearly half the industry is guessing, and misattributed AI sales are quietly pushing budget toward the wrong channels.

3

eMarketer Prices the Agentic Ad Market at $5 Billion

Who: Agency Executives, Media Planners and Buyers, Investors, Ad Tech Strategists

What: U.S. agentic media transactions will surpass $5 billion in 2027, according to eMarketer's inaugural agentic media buying forecast, with walled gardens like Amazon and Meta driving early adoption through their MCP connections. By 2028, principal analyst Yory Wurmser expects agentic buying to account for 10% of U.S. programmatic display spending, with cross-platform agent-to-agent transactions passing $9 billion plus another $20 billion in single-platform agentic buying. Open standards enabled the first agentic sales, the report notes, but walled gardens will bring the model to scale before open-web publishers catch up.

Why it matters: The first credible market sizing for agentic buying gives everyone a number to plan against — and its shape is a warning. The walled gardens win the first wave because they own both sides of the transaction. Independent ad tech's window to matter is the cross-platform phase, which eMarketer says arrives fast.

Reserve your spot at CIMA’s Holiday Party on Dec 10 in Chicago.

Will you be at CES 2027? Join us for Hot Takes & Happy Hours.

This January, Marketecture is bringing a little throwback Vegas magic to CES, with a retro revival built for Ad Tech’s biggest week.

If you’ll be in Vegas the first week of January, we’d love to have you bring your perspective to Marketecture’s Fabulous Hot Takes, our series of quick-hit interviews with the people driving the industry forward. 

Then keep the conversation going at AdTechGod® Retro Revival, an evening of cocktails, connections, and old-school Vegas glamour.

Ready to make your mark?

Celebrate old Vegas and new legends with us.

Marketecture Live IV Speakers and Early Bird Pricing are LIVE 👀

The room every marketer wants to be in is returning to New York City and now, we have our first look at who will be driving the conversations on stage this spring.

On March 9-10, 2027, Marketecture Live will be back at The Glasshouse NYC for a two-day event that will convene leading executives across brands, agencies, publishers, and adtech.

Wondering what the hype is all about? Marketecture Live takes a different approach: expertise first, no panels, no filler, no fluff. Across more than 40 sessions and breakouts, every conversation is designed to be sharp, relevant, and worth your time.

The event has consistently sold out, so don’t wait to lock in your ticket at the best price you’ll find.

Get to know our speakers and register today.

We're hiring for two (2) full-time roles to help us make an even bigger impact across the advertising ecosystem.

Know someone great? Send them our way! Think that's you? Check our Careers page and apply. We'd love to hear from you!

LATEST ON MARKETECTURE

Liking AI Brief? The Refresh is a weekly recap of all the most important advertising news, written by AdTechGod.

Thanks for reading this week’s AI BRIEF by Marketecture. 

Marketecture Media is committed to bringing you the latest news, opinions, and community updates. 

If you are interested in advertising on this newsletter, our podcasts, The Advertising Forum, or in our Slack community, you can contact us here.